2012
Elizabeth Phillips
Cross Country, Indoor and Outdoor Track and Field
Washington University in St. Louis

2011
Laura Barito
Swimming and Track 
Stevens Institute of Technology

2010
Justine Schluntz
Swimming
University of Arizona

2009
Lacey Nymeyer
Swimming
University of Arizona

2008
Nkolika Anosike
Basketball
University of Tennessee

2007
Whitney Myers
Swimming
University of Arizona

2006
Anne Bersagel
Cross Country/Track
Wake Forest University

2005
Lauryn McCalley
Diving
University of Tennessee, Knoxville

2004
Kelly Albin
Lacrosse
University of California, Davis

2003
Ashley Jo Rowatt
Swimming and Diving
Kenyon College

2002
Tanisha Silas
Track and Field
University of California, Davis

2001
Kimberly A. Black
Swimming
University of Georgia

2000
Kristy Kowal
Swimming
University of Georgia

1999
Jamila Demby
Track and Field
University of California, Davis

1998
Peggy Boutilier
Lacrosse and Field Hockey
University of Virginia

1997
Lisa Ann Coole
Swimming and Diving
University of Georgia

1996
Billie Winsett Fletcher
Volleyball
University of Nebraska

1995
Rebecca Lobo
Basketball
University of Connecticut

1994
Tanya Jones
Track and Field
University of Arizona

1993
Nnenna Lynch
Cross Country and Track and Field
Villanova University

1992
Catherine Byrne
Swimming and Diving
University of Tennessee

1991
Mary Beth Riley
Track and Field
Canisius College