2008 - Nkolika Anosike
Basketball, University of Tennessee
Video
Nine Finalists
Top 30 Conference and Independent Nominees
All 130 Conference and Independent Nominees

2007 - Whitney Myers
Swimming, University of Arizona
Video
Nine Finalists
Top 30 Conference and Independent Nominees
All 128 Conference and Independent Nominees

2006 - Anne Bersagel
Cross Country/Track, Wake Forest University
Finalists, Conference Winners, Video

2005 - Lauryn McCalley
Diving, University of Tennessee, Knoxville
Finalists, State Winners, Video

2004- Kelly Albin
Lacrosse, University of California, Davis
Finalists, State Winners, Video

2003 - Ashley Jo Rowatt
Swimming and Diving, Kenyon College
Finalists, State Winners, Video

2002 - Tanisha Silas
Track and Field, University of California, Davis
Finalists,  State Winners, Video

2001 - Kimberly A. Black
Swimming, University of Georgia
Finalists, State Winners,  Photos, Video

2000 - Kristy Kowal
Swimming, University of Georgia
Finalists, State Winners

1999 - Jamila Demby
Track and Field, University of California, Davis
Finalists, State Winners

1998 - Peggy Boutilier
Lacrosse and Field Hockey, University of Virginia
Finalists, State Winners

1997 - Lisa Ann Coole
Swimming and Diving, University of Georgia
Finalists, State Winners

1996 - Billie Winsett-Fletcher
Volleyball, University of Nebraska
Finalists, State Winners

1995 - Rebecca Lobo
Basketball, University of Connecticut
Finalists, State Winners

1994 - Tanya Jones
Track and Field, University of Arizona
Finalists, State Winners

1993 - Nnenna Lynch
Cross Country and Track and Field, Villanova University
Finalists, State Winners

1992 - Catherine Byrne
Swimming and Diving, University of Tennessee
Finalists, State Winners

1991 - Mary Beth Riley
Track and Field, Canisius College
Finalists, State Winners